The Bigot

Ben Chapman

Ben Chapman

By now I presume most of you have seen the movie “42” about the arrival of Jackie Robinson in the Major Leagues. One of the better performances in the flick is Alan Tudyk’s turn as Phillies manager Ben Chapman. For the purposes of the movie, Chapman becomes the symbol of all the hatred among players and managers aimed at Robinson and Tudyk’s wonderful job makes Chapman particularly odious. Of course Chapman wasn’t the only person who tossed slurs at Robinson, but he’s become, over the years, the ultimate symbol of racial bigotry in the Major Leagues, with only Cap Anson getting anything like equal billing.

Alan Tudyk as Chapman in "42"

Alan Tudyk as Chapman in “42”

William Benjamin Chapman was born in Tennessee on Christmas day in 1908. He was good at baseball and caught the eye of professional scouts. He spent 1928 and 1929 in the minors, then arrived in New York in 1930 as a backup third baseman and part-time second baseman for the Yankees. He hit .316 with 10 home runs, stole 14 bases, and 74 runs (it’s 1930, remember?). That got him a fulltime job, but not as an infielder. He moved to the outfield, splitting time between right field and left field (essentially playing whichever Babe Ruth wasn’t playing that day). He continued to hit well, leading the American League in stolen bases three times (and also leading in caught stealing four times). He was part of the 1932 Yankees World Series winning team, hitting .294 (his season average was .299) with a run, six RBIs, and an OPS of .780. He remained with New York through 1935 continuing to hit around .300 (.289 in 1935 was his low) and playing a decent, but not spectacular outfield. He led the AL in errors twice, but sources attribute that to his ability to get to balls slower men couldn’t even pretend to catch. He made three All Star teams (1933, ’34,’ and ’35) By 1934 and 1935 he was spending more time in center than either of the corner outfield slots. The next season the Yanks brought up Joe DiMaggio and Chapman was traded.

He ended up in Washington after 36 games in New York. He was still good enough to make another All Star team. In 1937 he was traded to Boston (the Red Sox, not the Braves) and led the AL one more time with 35 stolen bases.  He hit well enough in Boston but with diminishing speed and little power, he was traded to Cleveland in 1939. Now over 30, his numbers were slipping and he saw himself traded one more time. He went back to Washington in 1941, lasted 28 games, and was sent on to the White Sox.

He spent 1942 managing in the minors. In 1943 he was suspended for the season after slugging an umpire, then returned to minor league managing in 1944. He turned his career around by becoming a pitcher and resurfaced in the Majors in late 1944 with the Brooklyn Dodgers. Yep, that’s Jackie Robinson’s Brooklyn Dodgers; the irony is stunning.  He went 5-3 mostly as a starter, then after going 3-3 in early 1945, he was sent to Philadelphia. He played a few games in the outfield in this last stage of his career, but he remained primarily a pitcher. He got into one final game with Philadelphia in 1946 and ended his big league playing career (he got into a few games for Gadsden in 1949).

By this point he was managing the Phils, having taken over about midway through the 1945 season. Philadelphia finished eighth. He got them to fifth in 1946, then back to eighth in 1947. Seventy-nine games into 1948, with Philadelphia in eighth place, Chapman was fired. Many sources blame his reaction to Robinson for his firing, and that may be true. But it’s also true his teams weren’t winning and the universal fate of losing managers is firing. His comments to Robinson may simply have been the final blow. In partial defense of Chapman as a manager, it’s not like the Phils were the 1927 Yankees or anything. They weren’t very good. Even John McGraw would have had trouble making this team a contender. Having said that, you can see the beginning of the 1950 “Whiz Kids” pennant winner starting to come together under Chapman. Del Ennis is there, Dick Sisler shows up, and finally in 1948 both Richie Ashburn and Robin Roberts show up. He simply doesn’t win with them.

After retirement, Chapman sold insurance in Alabama, worked with high school baseball teams, and sat through a series of interviews, most of which wanted to talk about Robinson. He died largely forgotten in 1993.

For his career his triple slash line is .302/.383/.440/.823 with an OPS+ of 114. He had 1958 hits, scored 1144 runs, and had 977 RBIs. He hit 287 home runs, stole 287 bases (try doing that on purpose), but had a huge number of caught stealing. He ended up with 2849 total bases, and was 8-6 as a pitcher. All in all it’s not a bad career. His Baseball WAR is 41.4. And his managerial record is 196-276. Baseball has a similarity chart at the bottom of each player page. This tells you what other player this person is most like statistically. Interesting for Chapman, it’s Dixie Walker, the guy who started the petition to keep Robinson off the Dodgers. Funny how that works.

But of course Chapman is known for one thing, his virulent opposition to Jackie Robinson. And it has become simply the sole thing anyone knows about him. When I first saw Tudyk’s portrayal of Chapman I was stunned. Stunned not so much at the words he used on the field, but at the words he used to justify his actions. I’d heard them all my life from people I knew. “They don’t mind it. They know it’s just good-natured ribbing. They do it to us. All of us do it to each other and no body cares.” I found an interview with Chapman done in the 1970s where he still spouts the same thing. He’s also simply astounded and still shaken that no one seems to understand. In fact he never seemed to understand himself why people were repelled by his comments and actions. To me, that’s really the great tragedy of Chapman’s life and career. He never seemed to understand why he was seen as a jerk. (Or just possibly he’s fooled us all and knew exactly what he was doing and understood that his one chance for redemption was to act like he was a fool.) One of the best parts of Tudyk’s interpretation of Chapman is his ability to convey just how totally clueless Chapman was as to why he was being hounded. If Chapman had thought for even a minute about it he may have seen just how much his hounding of Robinson was much like what he himself was going through. But that presupposes a depth of self-perception that Chapman lacked.

Chapman's grave in Birmingham

Chapman’s grave in Birmingham

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

12 Responses to “The Bigot”

  1. William Miller Says:

    I never realized he hit so many home runs. Man, that practically makes him a superstar of his era.
    Nice post,

  2. Tall Tales and True Stories Says:

    This is excellent, V. You captured what a total sleazeball and lowlife Ben Chapman was very well.

    I just want to add that Chapman was an equal-opportunity racist— he seemed to hate everyone. Well, at least African-Americans and Jews.

    When he was a Yankee during the 1930s, he was known to yell anti-Semitic slurs towards the stands at Yankee Stadium. This must have really enamored him to Jewish Yankee fans.

    He also purposely spiked Buddy Myer of the Senators, as described by Shirley Povich in the article that I’m linking here. He also yelled anti-Semitic slurs at a Jewish GI who had lost his leg at the Polo Grounds (I assume that he lost his leg in battle, and not at the Polo Grounds.) This is all in the article that I am linking here from an article that was printed in the Jewish Exponent (a Jewish newspaper in Philadelphia) in 1999.

    Yes, it’s safe to say that Chapman was a pretty reprehensible person, unless, like Governor Wallace of Alabama, he changed his ways later on in his life.

    Here’s the article. Incidentally, it was co-written by Stephen H. Norwood of the Department of History at the University of Oklahoma.

    Click to access jsh2601f.pdf


  3. Tall Tales and True Stories Says:

    It didn’t link. Let me try it again.

    Click to access jsh2601f.pdf

  4. Tall Tales and True Stories Says:

    Let me also correct myself. This came from a publication called “The Journal of Sports History”, not the Exponent. I got it mixed up with some other article I read online that was from the Exponent about anti-Semitism against Ken Holtzman by members of the Yankees that I read a while back.


  5. Tall Tales and True Stories Says:

    I just reblogged your post, V, on my own blog.


    • verdun2 Says:

      thanks, Glen. Twice you sent me an offer to get on your new private blog. Tried both times. All I got was sent to my own reader. No idea what’s going on, but thought I ought to let you know. Did send wordpress a request to join. we’ll see what happens there.

  6. Tall Tales and True Stories Says:

    It’s weird. I don’t fully understand WordPress. By the way, it’s the same blog, but I made it private. That’s the only difference. W.K. Kortas was able to get in. I don’t know if it was easy for him or not. My sister got in, and she doesn’t have a blog of any kind, WordPress or otherwise. I don’t know. I’ll ask W.K. how he was able to get in.


  7. Tall Tales and True Stories Says:

    You should be able to read my blog now, V. I got a thing in my e-mail that said that you were requesting to be able to read it, and clicked the things that would enable you to do so. Let me know if it worked! Thanks!


  8. steve Says:

    I don’t know much about Chapman, but your insight reads like a bulls eye

    “Or just possibly he’s fooled us all and knew exactly what he was doing and understood that his one chance for redemption was to act like he was a fool.”

    And if that’s the case, he sort of did Robinson and breaking the color barrier a favor by sacrificing himself as the fool. Intentionally or unintentionally, he allowed the baseball world to understand ever so slowly that a person’s race had nothing to do with their personality, character, or playing ability.

    • verdun2 Says:

      I learned a long time ago from watching politicians that a lot of people figure they can get on better if they lead everyone to believe they’re stupid rather than venal. I don’t know if Chapman was swift enough to think like that, but I thought I ought to mention it just in case.
      thanks for reading and welcome aboard.

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: