Carl Erskine

Carl Erskine

If Don Newcombe was the most storied pitcher of the “Boys of Summer” Brooklyn Dodgers, Carl “Oisk” Erskine was easily second.

Erskine was born in Indiana in 1926. He played sandlot and high school ball and was good enough that he was noticed by the Brooklyn Dodgers. While in the Navy, Erskine signed with the Dodgers, but had his contract voided by the commissioner when it was learned he was still in the Navy (there was a rule against that). Despite other and bigger offers, he resigned with Brooklyn  and joined their minor league team at Danville in 1946. He pitched two years at Danville before transferring to Fort Worth in 1948. He stayed two years in Ft. Worth before playing one final minor league season in Montreal in 1950. He also played winter league ball in Cuba where he shared the field with black players and was managed by Martin DiHigo.

His Major League career began in 1948 when he was called up in 1948. He went 6-3 in 17 games (nine starts), tore a muscle in his back (it never healed properly and would bother him for his entire career), then began 1949 in the minors. Again he came up at the end of the season, went 8-1 in 22 games (three starts), and helped Brooklyn to the National League pennant. He got into two games in the World Series going 2.1 innings, giving up three runs, and posting an ERA north of 16. The Dodgers lost the Series in five games and Erskine had no decisions.

With the torn muscle still a problem, he started his last minor league campaign in 1950. He was called up early this time getting into 22 games, winning seven and losing six. After 1950 he would remain in the Major Leagues for the remainder of his career. The 1951 season saw him become a regular in the Dodgers rotation. He went 16-12, and helped lead Brooklyn to one of the more famous playoffs in MLB history. The Dodgers lost a three game playoff to the Giants (Bobby Thomson’s home run being the most famous moment). Erskine did not pitch in the playoff series.

He had a terrific 1952, going 14-6 with an ERA of 2.70. In June he pitched a no-hitter against the Cubs, walking only one man (the opposing pitcher). The Dodgers were back in the World Series at the end of the season. He lost game two of the Series on 2 October (his wedding anniversary), then won game five in 11 innings.  He also pitched the last couple of inning of a game seven loss without taking the decision.

In 1953, Erskine went 20-6, set a career high in strikeouts, and was the Dodgers ace. He started three games in the World Series, taking a no decision in game one, then came back to win game three and set the all-time record for strikeouts in a World Series game by fanning 14 Yankees, a record broken by a later teammate, Sandy Koufax (and later broken by Bob Gibson).  He started game six, but was not around when New York won the game 4-3 to clinch the Series.

Still in pain, Erskine would produce three more good years: 1954-56. In 1954 he would finally make an All Star team (his only one). In 1955 he would help his team win its only World Series. He started game four, took a no decision as the Dodgers won late, then didn’t pitch again for the remainder of the Series. In 1956, he would pitch his second no-hitter, this one at home against the Giants. He would get into one last World Series, losing game four as the Yankees took revenge for 1955.

Still hurting in 1957, he began slipping badly. By 1958 both he and the Dodgers were in Los Angeles, and he was given the honor of starting the first West Coast game. He got the win. It was easily the highlight of a forgettable year for both pitcher and team. In 1959, he started the year with LA, but retired during the season. The Dodgers made the World Series that year, winning in six games, but I’ve been unable to determine if he got a Series share.

For his career he was 122-78 with an ERA of 4.00 (ERA+ of 101). He gave up 1637 hits in 1718.2 innings, had 14 shutouts, walked 646, struck out 981, had two no hitters, and a WAR (Baseball Reference.com version) of 16.6. He never recovered from the muscle tear and finished his career at age 32.

In retirement he coached baseball at Anderson College winning four championships in 12 seasons. He also served as an insurance man and was chairman of the Indiana Bankers Association. Not a bad legacy for a sore-backed pitcher.

And for those curious, “Oisk” is a Brooklyn corruption of “Ersk”, the first part of his name.



Tags: , , , , , ,

5 Responses to “Oisk,”

  1. William Miller Says:

    Didn’t realize he’d thrown two no-hitters. He was always one of my favorites of The Boys of Summer. Seemed like a gentleman, too.
    Nice post,

  2. Thom Hickey Says:

    Thanks. A great pleasure to read this tribute! Regards .. Thom

  3. glenrussellslater Says:

    Bill is right. I can tell you from experience that Carl Erskine is a gentleman. Forgive me if I’ve related this story before.

    About ten years ago, my father and I went to a Brooklyn Dodgers thing at the Freeport (N.Y.) Recreation Center. I met lots of former Brooklyn Dodgers, such as Joe Pignatano, Dick Williams, Johnny Podres, and also Joan Hodges, the widow of Gil Hodges.

    And my father was kidding around most of the time there with Tommy Holmes, who was showing my father how to improve his batting swing (using a rolled up magazine or newspaper)! They were really cutting up and having a great time!

    After the thing was over (I don’t know what you’d call it. A card show? An autograph show? Whatever), my father and I were just sitting on a bench outside of the recreation center, right by the parking lot, just enjoying the nice weather. Some guy comes out, and as he passed us, he stopped, looked at my father’s Ebbets Field cap, and he gave him a playful nudge, hitting the brim of the cap and saying, “I like this cap!” He then smiled towards me; I was wearing a Brooklyn Dodgers cap, and he squeezed the brim of the cap and said, “I like THIS one, too!” He was a tall guy, but we didn’t know who he was.

    As he walked away, and was getting into his Cadillac, I hollered over, “Were you with the Dodgers?” He smiled at me and hollered back, “Yup! Carl Erskine!” And with that, he got into his car and drove away.

    I just sat there with my mouth wide open. Sure enough, there were Indiana license plates on the back of his car.

    It was Carl Erskine, allright.

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: